Both films used extensive amounts of dialog lifted directly from the novel. But yes, the newer film was more grittier when it came to the violence and humor of the story. The motion picture stands at the pinnacle of all art forms in our culture — where millions will flock to see the latest blockbuster.
I thought the film was well made but at the same time I had my problems with it. The character was a cantankerous ol rebel of the Wild West that was deadly with a pistol, enjoyed playing a post-meal game of cards with his friend, the shopkeeper Chin Lee and drinking his whiskey.
He also owned an orange tabby cat he called General Sterling Price.
Wayne had been in so many Westerns from the s on and True Grit was one of his last and best performances. He was basically playing himself which just made the film easier to get into and enjoy. The main problem I had with his characterization in True Grit was his speech. Rooster is such a complete marble mouth his dialogue becomes really tough to understand.
Another negative detail is Rooster and Mattie never really connect like they do in the film. There is no familial bond that we see form between them. Mattie Ross The main character Mattie Ross is a vengeful, serious, stubborn young girl who is out to get a criminal on the run named Tom Chaney the killer of her father and numerous other men.
Hailee Steinfeld shines in her role as the snappy, no nonsense Mattie. Throughout the film Steinfeld proves to be a formidable actress who can hold her own against all the male actors. Lucky Ned Pepper These dual performances are the closest for me between both films mainly because Barry Pepper has alot of the same dialogue as Robert Duvall did.
At first I wasnt even sure if it was him, then I recognized his face. They did a great job turning him into a dirty outlaw with crooked teeth and a weathered face. Pepper is always a solid actor who makes a project better.
Henry Hathaway who was one of the legendary old school directors in Hollywood went for a more traditional set up with his shots.
This made it easy to understand and had a broad appeal to audiences. Their aesthetic in this film really has more in common with something like a Tim Burton movie than a classic Hollywood western. The music between both films is another big difference.
Inthe score by Elmer Bernstein reflected the times and was more upbeat.
It featured the main song by Glenn Campbell which was a pop folksy ballad. The Coens version is downbeat, cold and unsentimental. We also learn that Mattie is a frigid old maid who seems to look down on everyone and for me this change actually ruined the entire film because of who I had hoped she would be in the end.
My personal choice between the two still is the first, lighter version of True Grit. What did you think?
Let us know in the comment section below!Dec 27, · Hailee Steinfeld’s Mattie Ross is notably younger than Kim Darby’s (which, at times, makes the new Mattie seem even more of an old movie concoction), and major sections of the picture are set at night (a technique that worked a lot better in No Country for Old Men).
TRUE GRIT: A Comparison by Peter · Published June 13, · Updated March 11, I recently watched the remake, or to be more precise the alternate adaptation of the book True Grit is based on directed by The Coen Brothers.
Mattie Ross: Then and Now It is no secret that as time goes on; characters in various pieces grow and change. Some of these characters change for the better, while some of them change for the worse.
In recent years, many film makers and producers have begun re-vamping old classics with mode. Dec 20, · The plucky Mattie Ross still plummets into that snake pit, although Hailee Steinfeld (born in ) is a much younger Mattie in today's version than . True Grit is a American western film. It is the first film adaptation of Charles Portis' novel of the same name.
The screenplay was written by Marguerite Roberts. The film was directed by Henry Hathaway and starred Kim Darby as Mattie Ross and John Wayne as U.S. Marshal Rooster grupobittia.com by: Elmer Bernstein. Dec 27, · Hailee Steinfeld’s Mattie Ross is notably younger than Kim Darby’s (which, at times, makes the new Mattie seem even more of an old movie concoction), and .